History of Don Garber's All Star Commissioner's Picks
Players in bold = home team selections.
Of the non-home team selections, Quaranta/Vaca were young stars perfect for this kind of showcase. Jones/Pope in 2007 were both in their final seasons. In 2004, Garber mentioned pairing Adu/Kreis as a "past and future" thing. 2006 featured two players coming back from injuries. Then there's Luis Hernandez, one of Garber's self-professed biggest mistakes. He certainly tried to get his money's worth out of that multi-million dollar transfer, the only player to be selected twice in these 11 years.