EDIT 12/20: RSL trades Harris to CHV for the 37th pick. I now have Chivas with only one pick in the draft. Also, you'd think MLS would've published the order by now...
EDIT 12/11: Ives reports that NY will give up their first rounder to Chicago for signing Osorio.
Also, now that RSL's 3rd rounder is not going to DC, I remember Buzz from 3rddegree saying that Dallas should have that pick due to Kreis' retirement (future considerations, I guess). I remember some confusion there, so that should be cleared up now since DC's out of the picture. So that's changed as well.
EDIT 12/7: Goff reports that DC has 3 picks: 24, 33, 52. I have them with 5 picks: 24, 28, 31, 33, 38. What are the differences? DC owes the Fire a conditional pick for Monteiro, so I'd already given the 52nd pick to the Fire. Turns out that Monteiro trade was for a third rounder, per his bio. Additionally, LA owes DC a conditional pick for Quaranta (1st or 2nd round). I gave United LA's worst 2nd rounder, the 28th pick. Usually, those conditional picks aren't usually exchanged until right before the draft. So I'm assuming that DC will get the pick from LA, and that the 38th pick (DC's natural 3rd rounder) will go to Chicago. Which then gives them back the 52nd.
So what about the 31st pick? I've listed DC with RSL's 3rd rounder due to the Adu trade, which was mentioned by Goff a while back. I've never seen any mention of it elsewhere, actually. Guess it was the "future considerations" mentioned when the trade was announced. Now, Goff has changed his story and said in the comments that he believes it's a 2009 pick. Actually, RSL has already traded their 2009 3rd rounder to KC. However, since he received that info from the team itself, I'll have to give RSL back the 31st pick here.
So that explains that.
EDIT 11/27: The Rapids should have NY's natural 4th rounder due to the Mathis trade. So I'm assuming that the 4th rounder they owe to LA for Quaranta will be the 51st instead. Also, included the Burpo deal.
EDIT 11/26: The Mathis pick is LA's natural pick. Also, NY has RSL's 4th rounder due to trading Rimando back to them. Thanks to Mooch on Soccerpubs. But RSL already had traded their fourth rounder to Dallas, so how does that work? According to the press release, RSL had Chivas' 4th rounder, how I don't know. So that gives NY the 51st pick and leaves Chivas with only one pick.
EDIT 11/19: Clint Mathis is traded to LA for a third rounder. No word yet on which one, so I just assumed the worst one (34th) would be given up. It's the 32nd pick, LA's natural pick.
EDIT (Post MLS-Cup): The order here is correct, and nothing changes from the original date of this post.
Currently, only the final four spots (11-14) are unknown. The MLS Cup winner will draft last, followed by the runner up, then followed by the two semifinal losers. So the positions could still change slightly, but this is pretty much set. The four first round playoff losers are ranked by their total points (7-10: NY, DAL, CHV, DC).
There's still a bit of guesswork with the conditional picks, and also there could be a trade or two that's unlisted. Please post in the comments if you have any additional knowledge.
Estimated 2008 Superdraft Order
Round One
1 | San Jose Earthquakes | 2 | FC Dallas | 3 | Real Salt Lake | 4 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 5 | Colorado Rapids | 6 | Columbus Crew | 7 | Chicago Fire
| 8 | FC Dallas | 9 | Toronto FC | 10 | Real Salt Lake | 11 | Kansas City Wizards | 12 | Chicago Fire | 13 | New England Revolution | 14 | Toronto FC |
Round Two
15 | San Jose Earthquakes | 16 | Red Bull New York | 17 | Real Salt Lake | 18 | Kansas City Wizards | 19 | FC Dallas | 20 | Columbus Crew | 21 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 22 | FC Dallas | 23 | Kansas City Wizards | 24 | DC United | 25 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 26 | Chicago Fire | 27 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 28 | DC United |
Round Three
29 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 30 | Toronto FC | 31 | FC Dallas
| 32 | Red Bull New York
| 33 | DC United | 34 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 35 | Colorado Rapids | 36 | Toronto FC | 37 | Real Salt Lake
| 38 | Chicago Fire
| 39 | Kansas City Wizards | 40 | Chicago Fire | 41 | New England Revolution | 42 | Houston Dynamo |
Round Four
43 | CD Chivas USA
| 44 | Red Bull New York | 45 | FC Dallas | 46 | Los Angeles Galaxy | 47 | Colorado Rapids | 48 | Columbus Crew | 49 | Colorado Rapids
| 50 | FC Dallas | 51 | Los Angeles Galaxy
| 52 | DC United
| 53 | Kansas City Wizards | 54 | Chicago Fire | 55 | New England Revolution | 56 | Houston Dynamo |
Total picks & Positions
CHI | 6 picks | 7, 12, 26, 38, 40, 54 | CHV | 1 pick | 43
| CLB | 3 picks | 6, 20, 48 | COL | 4 picks | 5, 35, 47, 49
| DAL | 7 picks | 2, 8, 19, 22, 31, 54, 50 | DC | 4 picks | 24, 28, 38, 52
| HOU | 2 picks | 42, 56 | KC | 5 picks | 11, 18, 23, 39, 53 | LA | 8 picks | 4, 21, 25, 27, 29, 34, 46, 51
| NE | 3 picks | 13, 41, 55 | NY | 3 picks | 16, 32, 44
| RSL | 4 picks | 3, 10, 17, 37
| SJ | 2 picks | 1, 15 | TOR | 4 picks | 9, 14, 30, 36 |
Trade/Pick Movement List
Round 1
DAL has TOR's pick (Mulrooney trade) TOR has HOU's pick (Mulrooney trade) TOR has CHV's pick (Nagamura trade) RSL has 2nd highest of TOR's 3 picks (Cunningham trade) TOR has DC's pick (Dyachenko trade) CHI has NY's pick (Osorio compensation)
Round 2
NY has TOR's pick (Wynne trade) LA has HOU's pick (Jaqua trade) KC has LA's pick (Thomas trade, conditional) DAL has COL's pick (Vanney trade) LA has KC's pick (Hartman trade) LA has NY's pick (Wolyniec trade) LA has NE's pick (allocation/1st rounder trade)
Round 3
DC has COL's natural pick (Prideaux trade) TOR has COL's pick, presumably one of the two listed next (Casey trade) COL has NY's pick (Freeman trade) COL has DAL's pick (Vanney trade) LA has CLB's pick (Miglioranzi trade, conditional) LA has SJ's pick (Yallop deal) NY has LA's pick (Mathis trade) CHI has DC's pick (Monteiro trade, conditional) RSL has CHV's pick (Harris trade)
??? - DC has RSL's pick (Adu trade)
Round 4
DAL has RSL's pick (4th rounder trade) NY has TOR's pick (Ibrahim trade) NY has RSL's pick, via CHV (Rimando trade) CHV has SJ's pick (Burpo deal)
Other
KC has CHV's pick (Zotinca trade, conditional: 2nd or 3rd round) DC has LA's pick (Quaranta trade, conditional: 1st or 2nd round) LA has NY's pick (Quaranta trade, conditional: 4th rounder)
I counted the first two trades as a 2nd rounder, and a 2nd rounder. I assumed the worst pick would be given up.
Supplemental Trades
COL has RSL's 1st round pick (Wingert trade) NE has DAL's 1st round pick (salary cap considerations trade) CHI has CLB's 4th round pick (Griffin trade) |