Wednesday, March 16, 2011

CTL on MLSsoccer.com - Column #2

Climbing the Ladder: Home-field advantage

Something I've discussed before in years past. For the person who left the comment about whether or not I'd be able to count shootouts as draws, here's your answer. However, that doesn't mean I'm going to just act like my records are official and the league's aren't. I'll use the official stats unless there's a reason not to, like with this kind of analysis.

For further reading, I recommend this article on the possible causes of HFA.

The Harvard study referenced, which involved the EPL and attendance, can be found here (well, a summary of it).

Labels: ,

Wednesday, May 05, 2010

MLS Home Field Advantage - Updated

Updated through the 2009 season. To make this more interesting, I've compiled the data for the English Premiership over the same years so we have something to compare the MLS data with. Below, you'll see how many points on average home and away teams receive in both leagues, as well as the number of goals.

Performance of Home Teams in Major League Soccer

Year Games W L D H-PPG A-PPG Diff
1996 160 84 42 34 1.79 1.00 0.79
1997 160 81 46 33 1.73 1.07 0.66
1998 192 101 58 33 1.75 1.08 0.67
1999 192 80 55 57 1.55 1.16 0.39
2000 192 105 53 34 1.82 1.01 0.81
2001 158 83 47 28 1.75 1.07 0.68
2002 140 77 41 22 1.81 1.04 0.77
2003 150 71 38 41 1.69 1.03 0.66
2004 150 72 32 46 1.75 0.95 0.80
2005 192 92 56 44 1.67 1.10 0.56
2006 192 92 44 56 1.73 0.98 0.75
2007 195 91 54 50 1.66 1.09 0.57
2008 210 106 47 57 1.79 0.94 0.84
2009 225 107 49 69 1.73 0.96 0.77








Total 2508 1242 662 604 1.73 1.03 0.69

The column furthest to the right is the key here, that's the home field advantage. Over 14 seasons and 2,508 games, home teams on average gain 0.69 more points than away teams. With the current 30 game season, that means that a team that played all its games at home would expect to gain an average of 21 points over a team that played an even schedule.

So far in 2010, the advantage has been 1.20 PPG, which is sure to come down.


Performance of Home Teams in the English Premier League

Year Games W L D H-PPG A-PPG Diff
1995/6 380 186 96 98 1.73 1.02 0.71
1996/7 380 162 99 119 1.59 1.09 0.50
1997/8 380 184 101 95 1.70 1.05 0.66
1998/9 380 169 96 115 1.64 1.06 0.58
1999/0 380 187 101 92 1.72 1.04 0.68
2000/1 380 184 95 101 1.72 1.02 0.70
2001/2 380 165 114 101 1.57 1.17 0.40
2002/3 380 187 103 90 1.71 1.05 0.66
2003/4 380 167 105 108 1.60 1.11 0.49
2004/5 380 173 97 110 1.66 1.06 0.60
2005/6 380 192 111 77 1.72 1.08 0.64
2006/7 380 182 100 98 1.69 1.05 0.65
2007/8 380 176 104 100 1.65 1.08 0.57
2008/9 380 173 110 97 1.62 1.12 0.50








Total 5320 2487 1432 1401 1.67 1.07 0.59

The EPL ends up with a slightly different number: a 0.59 PPG home field advantage. It makes sense for MLS to have a higher HFA due to having a more balanced league. Comparing the two leagues percentage wise, the home teams' W-L-D results are 50-26-24 for MLS and 47-27-26 for the EPL. Home teams win 62% of the points in MLS vs 58% in the EPL.


Number of Home & Away Goals in Major League Soccer

Year Games Gol GPG HG AG HGPG AGPG Diff
1996 160 539 3.37 321 218 2.01 1.36 0.64
1997 160 522 3.26 302 220 1.89 1.38 0.51
1998 192 685 3.57 391 294 2.04 1.53 0.51
1999 192 549 2.86 305 244 1.59 1.27 0.32
2000 192 612 3.19 351 261 1.83 1.36 0.47
2001 158 519 3.28 297 222 1.88 1.41 0.47
2002 140 421 3.01 246 175 1.76 1.25 0.51
2003 150 433 2.89 248 185 1.65 1.23 0.42
2004 150 392 2.61 234 158 1.56 1.05 0.51
2005 192 551 2.87 306 245 1.59 1.28 0.32
2006 192 503 2.62 293 210 1.53 1.09 0.43
2007 195 518 2.66 297 221 1.52 1.13 0.39
2008 210 591 2.81 355 236 1.69 1.12 0.57
2009 225 571 2.54 340 231 1.51 1.03 0.48









Total 2508 7406 2.95 4286 3120 1.71 1.24 0.46

Again, the far right number is the most important one. So in MLS, the home teams score an average of 0.46 more goals per game than the away teams.


Number of Home & Away Goals in the English Premier League

Year Games Gol GPG HG AG HGPG AGPG Diff
1995/6 380 988 2.60 580 408 1.53 1.07 0.45
1996/7 380 970 2.55 559 411 1.47 1.08 0.39
1997/8 380 1019 2.68 592 427 1.56 1.12 0.43
1998/9 380 959 2.52 553 406 1.46 1.07 0.39
1999/0 380 1060 2.79 635 425 1.67 1.12 0.55
2000/1 380 992 2.61 587 405 1.54 1.07 0.48
2001/2 380 1001 2.63 557 444 1.47 1.17 0.30
2002/3 380 1000 2.63 570 430 1.50 1.13 0.37
2003/4 380 1012 2.66 572 440 1.51 1.16 0.35
2004/5 380 975 2.57 570 405 1.50 1.07 0.43
2005/6 380 944 2.48 555 389 1.46 1.02 0.44
2006/7 380 931 2.45 552 379 1.45 1.00 0.46
2007/8 380 1002 2.64 581 421 1.53 1.11 0.42
2008/9 380 942 2.48 532 410 1.40 1.08 0.32









Total 5320 13795 2.59 7995 5800 1.50 1.09 0.41

A similar difference in the EPL at 0.41, despite a much lower goals per game average. Home teams have scored 57.9% of the goals in MLS vs 58.0% in the EPL.

Labels: ,

Monday, October 05, 2009

Home Field Dis-Advantage

A lot has been made this year over the home struggles of the Chicago Fire and the Los Angeles Galaxy. The Fire are doing much better away (1.64 PPG) than at home (1.29 PPG). The Galaxy were in that same boat, but they've won their last two home games and are now sporting equal marks (1.57 PPG) home and away. The Wizards are also close to being equal (home = 4-5-4, away = 4-6-4).

What the Fire and Galaxy are doing is rare historically in Major League Soccer. I've covered home field advantage before; the number is around 0.67 PPG for all of MLS history. So for the Fire to have a -0.35, that's on pace for the second lowest mark in league history. In fact, only nine of the 149 team seasons from 1996-2008 have seen a team's away record be equal to or better than their home record. Those teams are:



Home Away
Diff
1999 New York 0.625 0.625
0.000
1998 Tampa Bay 1.188 1.250
-0.063
2003 San Jose 1.667 1.733
-0.067
1997 San Jose 1.063 1.188
-0.125
1999 Tampa Bay 1.125 1.313
-0.188
1998 Los Angeles 2.063 2.313
-0.250
1999 DC United 1.750 2.000
-0.250
2003 New York 1.267 1.533
-0.267
2002 New York 1.000 1.500
-0.500

A mix of teams good and bad. There are two MLS Cup winners in the group, though both excelled in both categories (like 2009 LA) rather than being poor at home (2009 CHI). As always, I'm counting shootouts as draws.

How have these nine teams done in the playoffs? Would you expect them to do better on the road there as well? First, four of them failed to qualify. Of the other five, the results are as follows:

  • LA 1998. Easily disposed of the Dallas Burn in round one, winning home and away. They lost to Chicago after a 0:1 home loss and a 1:1 away draw (shootout loss). So they did slightly better away.
  • TB 1999. Swept out of the playoffs after equal 0:2 results away and home against Columbus.
  • DC 1999. Won the MLS Cup after winning the Supporters' Shield. They played much better at home in those playoffs. Started off by sweeping Miami in two games after a home win and an away draw (shootout win). Defeated Columbus by winning both home games in between a 1:5 shellacking in Crew Stadium.
  • NY 2003. Lost the opener vs NE at home 0:2, then drew 1:1 away to lose by two on aggregate.
  • SJ 2003. Won the MLS Cup after famously coming back from four goals down on aggregate in the quarterfinals (at home). Won both home games and lost the only away game.
It's interesting that neither of the MLS Cup winners in this group got there by getting an away result in the playoffs. They both played much better at home. Of course, as I mentioned earlier both were excellent in both categories in the regular season (so basically, they were good wherever they played).

Anyway, expecting home and/or away form to carry over into the small sample size that is the MLS playoffs isn't very realistic. One of the top ten disparities on the other side (that is, playing much, much better at home) was last year's New York Red Bulls, and they ended up winning two straight away games to make the final.

I don't expect the home/away records of Chicago and LA to have an impact on this year's playoffs. I certainly don't think Fire fans should want their team to get a lower seed so they can play more away games. That's not going to help.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Open Cup - Home & Away

We all know that the Open Cup matchups are not a random draw like the FA Cup. Teams are matched together by region, and deciding who hosts is based on which teams bid for it. It's hard not to notice how some teams always seem to play at home or away. For example, DC United has hosted every Open Cup match they've played in 2008 and 2009 so far. They'll also host the semifinal against Rochester.

It's obvious that everyone would like to see a random draw implemented eventually, but it doesn't make financial sense (especially for the lower league teams) right now. That's not what this post is about. Instead, I thought it would be interesting to see how many Open Cup winners have played more away games than home games en route to the title.

The answer? Since 1996, it's happened only once. That would be the 1997 Dallas Burn, who played three away games and won the championship at a neutral site.

Right now, Houston has won twice away at Austin and Charleston. They're scheduled to play at Seattle in the semis, so they would join the 1997 Burn if they go on to win the whole thing.

I would expect DC not to get the final at home if they make it again. It would be too unfair to have the same team host it twice in a row. That hasn't happened so far in MLS history despite two chances; Columbus hosted instead of LA in 2002, and Chicago hosted LA in 2006.

Seattle is the obvious choice to host the final if they make it that far with the crowds they've been getting. Houston would likely host against DC (no college conflict, and United play in Dallas a few days later), while the Dynamo against the Rhinos would be up in the air. I'd imagine Houston would probably get to host that matchup too, given the good crowds they've got for important playoff games in the past and the previously mentioned run of away games.

Open Cup Winners - Home/Away/Neutral Breakdown

1996 DC United 2-1
1997 Dallas 0-3-1
1998 Chicago 1-1-2
1999 Rochester 3-0-2
2000 Chicago 3-2
2001 Los Angeles 4-1
2002 Columbus 3-1
2003 Chicago 2-2
2004 Kansas City 3-1
2005 Los Angeles 3-1
2006 Chicago 4-0
2007 New England 2-2
2008 DC United 4-0

Notes:

The Fire played away matches against the Chicago Stingers/Sockers (same team, just changed the name) in 1998 and 2000, at Forest View Park. Now the Fire did play a US Open Cup match against another team there in 2000, but that was the regular stadium of the Stingers/Sockers so I think officially it was an away match.

The 1997 & 1999 finals were hosted by neutral sites. Teams that have hosted the final are 9-2, the only losses were in 2003 (New York) and 2007 (Dallas).

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 04, 2009

Home Field Advantage in the Hex

There's no shame in losing to Costa Rica. A draw would've been nice, but a win? It's really difficult to come by away from home. Just to show you how hard it is, here's how home teams have performed over the past four hexes (W-L-D):

1998
: 15-2-13
2002: 14-10-6
2006: 20-6-4
2010: 7-0-3 (so far)

Total: 56-18-26

There have only been 18 away wins in 100 games. The top three teams (USA, Mexico, Costa Rica) each have only one home loss in that total.


Home Field Advantage

(measured by PPG)

1998 1.30
2002 0.40
2006 1.40
2010 2.10 (so far)


Total 1.14

The average home team has gotten 1.94 PPG vs 0.80 for away teams, for a home field advantage of 1.14 PPG. For perspective, the all time home field advantage in MLS is around 0.67 PPG.


List of away wins

(sorted by cycle)

El Salvador 0:1 Mexico
Canada 0:3 USA

Honduras 1:2 USA
Mexico 1:2 Costa Rica
Trinidad 2:4 Honduras
Trinidad 1:2 Jamaica
Honduras 2:3 Costa Rica
USA 2:3 Honduras
Trinidad 0:2 Costa Rica
Jamaica 1:2 Mexico
Honduras 0:1 Trinidad
Jamaica 0:1 Costa Rica

Costa Rica 1:2 Mexico
Trinidad 1:2 USA
Guatemala 0:2 Mexico
Panama 0:3 USA
Panama 1:3 Costa Rica
Panama 0:1 Trinidad

(none yet in 2010)

Labels: , ,

Monday, June 01, 2009

MLS Week 11 Notes

1) Jeff Cunningham is seven games away from history. At that point, he'll tie Jason Kreis for the dubious record of having played the most MLS regular season games without playing in an MLS Cup. See the top 25 post-2008 here. Kreis has held the record for three years now, but Cunningham should have it all to his own shortly.

2) The Colorado Rapids are second in the league for offense with 1.60 goals per game. If you have a gut feeling that it's unusual to see them scoring so frequently, then you're right. They've never finished higher than 4th in that category, and they've only been in the top half in two of thirteen years. I suppose looking back, they were on the right track last year, finishing 5th and breaking a nine year streak of lower half finishes.

3) New England's offense, on the other hand, has been pathetic. Maybe that'll change now that Taylor Twellman is back, but currently they're averaging a goal per game which is tied for worst in the league. They're also on pace to set two new records: Fewest shots per game (8.0) and fewest corner kicks per game (3.4). The current records are held by 2007 Toronto (9.2) and 2006 Dallas (3.5) respectively.

4) Chicago was the league's last undefeated team. How have those teams done in previous years? Usually pretty well, although the last two years (NY and Dallas) are exceptions. Before the past two years, every year a team in that category finished in the top three of the league (a couple years featured multiple teams tying for the last undefeated status).

Columbus was the league's last winless team, and the omens aren't good for them. Only once has such a team advanced past the first round of the playoffs (2002 NE).

I counted shootouts as draws in both these categories, and also I went by the number of games into the year rather than by the calendar.

5) Even though there have been plenty of draws (did you hear?), this year's home field advantage (0.68) is right in line with the all time average (around 0.67 PPG). So it's not like away teams are having a harder time getting points than in previous years.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Monday, May 04, 2009

Early Unbalanced

One thing that people need to consider when looking at the MLS standings is the number of home and away games played. Given that the all time home field advantage in MLS is about 0.67 PPG, that can be a pretty significant factor in a team's record this early on if their schedule is unbalanced. If a team has played 6, 7, or 8 games and they have two more home games than away or vice versa, than that's a big deal. Just look at last year's San Jose Earthquakes, who had a tremendously unbalanced home/away slate. Sure, they added Darren Huckerby among others, but they finished the year with 9 of 13 games at home (right when they went on a hot streak).

The five teams this year who have had a reasonably unbalanced schedule so far are as follows:

NE, NY - These two teams have played two more times away than home. That means they should be better than their records indicate. Now that doesn't necessarily mean that they are good teams. Just that their schedule may be hurting them a bit. For example, if you went by their home and away PPGs and gave them a balanced schedule, then NY should have 6.12 points instead of 5.

LA, SJ, TOR - These teams have played two more home games than away, or in the case of the Quakes it's three more which really doesn't bode well for them.

Labels: